One Hundred Million American Muslims Thank You, Mr President.

“The US is one of the largest Muslim countries in the world, [if you count….],” President Obama declared to a French television network, June 2nd.

Some falsehoods don’t matter much, others matter a great deal. It all depends on context. I may assert something factually incorrect because I am not thinking, or because I am not thinking about the particular topic at the moment and would have done better keeping my mouth shut. (There is a wonderful French expression: “To have missed a good opportunity to shut up.”)

The President’s false assertion does not get either of these two passes. It was made on the eve of a trip to the Middle-East his White House heralded an act of reconciliation with Muslims. He committed the falsehood two days before he was due to make a speech at prestigious and highly visible Cairo University. He assaulted the simple factual truth under the limelights. Muslims were on his mind, for sure.

Here are the facts:

The US has probably fewer then 3 million Muslims. (Yes, this includes “Black Muslims” and other dubious categories.) Supposing this number conceals an unprecedented undercount, let’s suppose it’s really 6 million. The highest figure ever advanced is 7 million and no one believes it. Let’s keep it anyway, just to show that I am giving the President every benefit of doubt.*

The country ranking number ten for the number of Muslims in its population is Morocco, with 32 million. That’s more than four times the highest possible estimate for American Muslims. You have to reach down to little Tunisia to begin approximating the highest American order of magnitude. For that matter, France probably has more Muslims than the US. (Figures from ReligionFacts, and from Wikipedia – for #2, India. I have made no mistakes that would support my argument)

We are left to believe that when Obama says, “largest” he means anything down to number 30 or, that he is lying or, that he does not know what he is talking about. I don’t see any other possibility. Do you?

Obviously, I don’t think he is lying, especially in front of the millions or billions of interested listeners. I am pretty sure he knows English well enough to not misuse a simple word such as, “largest.”

I believe he does not care. Furthermore, I think his staff does not care.

Here is a man with a regiment of speech-writers and an army of fact- checkers. He does not consult with them and they don’t find it necessary to put him on guard against exaggerations. This is a tribe of people who don’t think they need to be cautious about facts. The underlying attitude is enormous arrogance:

No one will check. They are a bunch of ignorant peasants; or,

The President’s discourse is so captivating that everyone’s critical sense is put to sleep, especially the Muslims’. They are already in love with him anyway.

I resent especially that this particular falsehood undermines our national credibility among alert, attentive, well-informed Muslims. Those are the very people whose esteem Americans must earn and keep. There are plenty of those. They know enormously more about us than we know about them. Many don’t have much more important to do than America-watching.

Besides, the false statement proceeds from another kind of patronizing arrogance that used to be familiar in this country but has almost disappeared. It’s reminiscent of old anti-Semites asserting, “Some of my best friends are Jewish.”

I don’t know about other Muslims but Arabs are often subtle, if they are anything. Arab culture promotes a very refined appreciation of words. Many Arabs will not miss the slight in the affirmation underlying the President’s falsehood: “We are almost one of you.” Pathetic!

I would not buy a used car from this President, or even a new car. Too bad I have no choice but to buy his disastrous economic policies.

Why are Pres. Obama’s grades still locked up? We know both G. W. Bush’s and Senator Kerry’s grades, so, why the secrecy? (Both Bush and Kerry were lousy students, Kerry worse than Bush.)

*Those figures are all from Wikipedia. I don’t give Wikipedia unlimited credibility in general except with items, such as this one, that are sure to have been scrutinized repeatedly by different parties.

Advertisements

About Jacques Delacroix

I am a sociologist, a short-story writer, and a blogger (Facts Matter and Notes On Liberty) in Santa Cruz, California.
This entry was posted in Current Events, Facts Matter and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to One Hundred Million American Muslims Thank You, Mr President.

  1. Astou Ka says:

    We are all in love with Mr. Obama because he is at least reaching out to us. He SEEMS to at least care about us. Whether he does or not, noone is in his heart to find out but actions do speak louder than words. Who cares if he makes a factual mistake about the number of Muslims in the U.S.? What’s important is that he is reaching out, taking a step towards better relationships unlike the cowboy right-wingers who believe all Muslims are evil.
    Again BRAVO Obama and Boooo uncle!!!!!!

    • jacquesdelacroix says:

      Note: The writer of the comment above is a foreign Muslim who lives in the US. She is pretty smart for her age but I suspect she is ill-informed about Muslim public opinion worldwide, if there is such a thing.

      Dear A. K.: You missed what I was saying: How can anyone make such a big mistake except if one does not care about facts?

  2. clambo slice says:

    The USA is not a muslim country. This is not to say some muslims do not live here. The distinction is lost on liberals, dimwits and accidental presidents.

  3. Alan Bailey says:

    Jacques,
    WRT Rokin’s PhD: The UCSC faculty directory and the Community Studies department faculty directory list him as a lecturer. No mention of PhD.

    However, on a website of his own, which is a city council campaign blurb, he claims a 1991 PhD in History of Consciousness (The Study of Staying Awake), as does another site sponsored by a SCAN front group.

    So I really don’t know for sure. But I’ve concluded, over the past 28 years of living in Santa Cruz and observing Rotkin, that he’s a pathological liar. To me, he seems to lie even when the truth would serve him better.

    Regards,
    WestSide Al

    • jacquesdelacroix says:

      Thanks. The title “lecturer” does not say anything about whether the person has a PhD or not. If you are still interested, UCSC should have a number to call or an email address about “degree verification.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s